How to make a keyring
Every month or two keyring-maint gets a comment about how a key update we say we’ve performed hasn’t actually made it to the active keyring, or a query about why the keyring is so out of date, or told that although a key has been sent to the HKP interface and that is showing the update as received it isn’t working when trying to upload to the Debian archive. It’s frustrating to have to deal with these queries, but the confusion is understandable. There are multiple public interfaces to the Debian keyrings and they’re not all equal. This post attempts to explain the interactions between them, and how I go about working with them as part of the keyring-maint team.
First, a diagram to show the different interfaces to the keyring and how they connect to each other:
Public interfaces
rsync: keyring.debian.org::keyrings
This is the most important public interface; it’s the one that the Debian infrastructure uses. It’s the canonical location of the active set of Debian keyrings and is what you should be using if you want the most up to date copy. The validity of the keyrings can be checked using the included sha512sums.txt
file, which will be signed by whoever in keyring-maint did the last keyring update.
HKP interface: hkp://keyring.debian.org/
What you talk to with gpg --keyserver keyring.debian.org
. Serves out the current keyrings, and accepts updates to any key it already knows about (allowing, for example, expiry updates, new subkeys + uids or new signatures without the need to file a ticket in RT or otherwise explicitly request it). Updates sent to this interface will be available via it within a few hours, but must be manually folded into the active keyring. This in general happens about once a month when preparing for a general update of the keyring; for example b490c1d5f075951e80b22641b2a133c725adaab8.
Why not do this automatically? Even though the site uses GnuPG to verify incoming updates there are still occasions we’ve seen bugs (such as #787046, where GnuPG would always import subkeys it didn’t understand, even when that subkey was already present). Also we don’t want to allow just any UID to be part of the keyring. It is thus useful to retain a final set of human based sanity checking for any update before it becomes part of the keyring proper.
Alioth/anonscm: https://anonscm.debian.org/git/keyring/keyring.git/
A public mirror of the git repository the keyring-maint team use to maintain the keyring. Every action is recorded here, and in general each commit should be a single action (such as adding a new key, doing a key replacement or moving a key between keyrings). Note that pulling in the updates sent via HKP count as a single action, rather than having a commit per key updated. This mirror is updated whenever a new keyring is made active (i.e. made available via the rsync interface). Until that point pending changes are kept private; we sometimes deal with information such as the fact someone has potentially had a key compromised that we don’t want to be public until we’ve actually disabled it. Every “keyring push” (as we refer to the process of making a new keyring active) is tagged with the date it was performed. Releases are also tagged with their codenames, to make it easy to do comparisons over time.
Debian archive
This is actually the least important public interface to the keyring, at least from the perspective of the keyring-maint team. No infrastructure makes use of it and while it’s mostly updated when a new keyring is made active we only make a concerted effort to do so when it is coming up to release. It’s provided as a convenience package rather than something which should be utilised for active verification of which keys are and aren’t currently part of the keyring.
Team interface
Master repository: kaufmann.debian.org:/srv/keyring.debian.org/master-keyring.git
The master git repository for keyring maintenance is stored on kaufmann.debian.org AKA keyring.debian.org. This system is centrally managed by DSA, with only DSA and keyring-maint having login rights to it. None of the actual maintenance work takes place here; it is a bare repo providing a central point for the members of keyring-maint to collaborate around.
Private interface
Private working clone
This is where all of the actual keyring work happens. I have a local clone of the repository from kaufmann
on a personal machine. The key additions / changes I perform all happen here, and are then pushed to the master repository so that they’re visible to the rest of the team. When preparing to make a new keyring active the changes that have been sent to the HKP interface are copied from kaufmann via scp
and folded in using the pull-updates
script. The tree is assembled into keyrings with a simple make
and some sanity tests performed using make test
. If these are successful the sha512sums.txt
file is signed using gpg --clearsign
and the output copied over to kaufmann. update-keyrings
is then called to update the active keyrings (both rsync + HKP). A git push public
pushes the changes to the public repository on anonscm. Finally gbp buildpackage --git-builder='sbuild -d sid'
tells git-buildpackage to use sbuild
to build a package ready to be uploaded to the archive.
Hopefully that helps explain the different stages and outputs of keyring maintenance; I’m aware that it would be a good idea for this to exist somewhere on keyring.debian.org as well and will look at doing so.