Too many secrets

FFS. If you're running a forum site (Ubuntu Forums, I'm currently looking at you, though you're not the only offender), please don't require logins to download attachments. It's really annoying and I'm fed up of having to create user accounts I'll only ever use once.

BarCamp Belfast 2008

I spent Saturday at BarCamp Belfast. There were more people than I expected; I'm no good at judging exact numbers but the wiki lists 62. As it turned out not everyone ended up talking; this worked out well for me because I don't think I'm Web2.0 enough (is that a bit ironic given I'm writing this on a blog?). I don't really do user interfaces or website stuff and that seemed to be the primary focus of a lot of the attendees. Nice to know there's a fairly active crowd in Belfast though; I discovered the existence of Belfast Open Coffee which I'll have to try and make at some point.

I went to at least the following talks::

Gerard McBreen on Digital Circle & Adobe Flex: Quite a cute demonstration of the Flex framework for Flash. I'd have been more convinced if Flash could be considered truly cross platform; Adobe can't even manage a 64 bit client yet and Gnash is far from ready.

Daniel McLaughlin on Nagios: Not really anything I didn't already know, but always interesting to see how other people are using these things to see if there's any nice tricks you've missed.

Andrew Gribbon from Exile Coffee on speciality coffee: This was really interesting. A complete tangent from IT but enjoyable and I must buy some roasted beans from him (I've been meaning to place a Roast and Post order for ages anyway).

Brian O'Neill on freelancing: Tailored towards the web market in my opinion, which is fair enough but things like aiming to never employ anyone and stay a one man operation doesn't really work if you're doing something that a customer wants supported around the clock. Or even just during the working day if you're crossing time zones. Interesting to hear that Brian had run an agency in the past but preferred working on his own these days. I kinda feel I've gone a bit the other way. :)

Linux Hardware workshop: Not really a lot of interest here; a clutch of EEEs, an N800 and a Debian box or two. However I had a chat with David Newman about his MythTV setup which convinced me I really should give it another try. After I get someone to install a bigger aerial in the hope of stabilising our Freeview reception.

Brian Cleland on Linux Trends: Talking about lots of Linux takeup by big names and general market adoption eg the recent selection of cheap subnotebooks. Main thing of interest was OpenPandora which I hadn't heard of before; OMAP3 based handheld device running Linux with a 800x480 4.3" screen. Aimed as a gaming device, but has a keyboard and bluetooth/wifi so has potential as a PDA as well. Hopefully the build quality will be better than the GP2X I saw.

Andy McMillan on coffee shop working: I've thought about this in the past myself; I worked from Cafe Java in Norwich a few times while doing Black Cat, but in general didn't find it as conducive to work as I'd hoped. He mentioned Coworking Belfast which is an idea Tristam has talked about in the past, in terms of people who work from home getting to have some form of social contact with like minded individuals, without having to go to the expense of a whole office. It'll be interesting to see if it takes off.

Darragh Doyle and Grannymar on blogging: I think everyone in the audience already had a blog of some description. I don't really consider my blog a social forum; it's not something I expect to have a long conversation on, just ask a quick question or discuss something I've done that I think might interest people or give a general "this is what's happening at present" post. Blog commenting systems are all a bit crap to keep up anything sustained. Someone needs to write a blog<>nntp gateway that correctly cross posts comments as well. I suppose the issue with that is then everyone needs to run a news server, or all agree on using the same one. Fine for groups of people who know each other but not if you want to read a dozen blogs from different areas in a single client that'll let you properly follow conversations. Mind you, people seem to cope with forums and I don't really understand how. Supporters of news and mailing lists seem to be dwindling. :(

Anyway, that was my first BarCamp. I wasn't quite sure what to expect, it was a bit more Web2.0 than I'd have liked (which is fair enough, but I'd have liked to have seen some talks about low level bits really) but I'd go again and will keep an eye out for the next one. And hopefully I'll see some of the people I met there at the BLUG meeting this Wednesday (Tap House in Lower Crescent from 6pm for anyone who's not on the mailing list).

BarCamp - What to say?

Dear Membersofthelazywebwhoknowme,

I am planning to attend BarCamp Belfast on Saturday. They seem to have this idea that everyone should talk about something. I can't think of anything particularly interesting I've done recently to talk about. What have I bored you about that you think might potentially be reasonable to bore a bunch of strangers about? I've been pondering the calendaring/syncing rant, but it really is just that rather than something with a nice conclusion...

Missing small IPv6 packets

I have this IPv6 issue with my ADSL. It's kinda bizarre and I'd be interested in whether anyone has any ideas or has seen anything similar themselves.

I don't get IPv6 packets smaller than 71 bytes (excluding the PPP header).

Small IPv4 packets? No problem. Sending small IPv6 packets? Also fine. Getting them back again? No go.

I first noticed the problem because I couldn't get to Google's IPv6 site. I ended up getting some quite useful help from various Google engineers, who were prepared to take my report seriously even though I'm just an end user these days. I've promised to get back to them with what the problem was when I find out. If.

My ADSL is provided by Enta, through a reseller. My parents also use them, but via a different reseller. My understanding is this shouldn't make a difference, as Enta are responsible for terminating the connection in both cases. On my parents' line IPv6 seems to work fine. They have a Linux box with a Conexant based PCI card. I have an AR7 router running OpenWRT. My first thought was that it might be some weird hardware issue, so I dug out my Speedtouch, hooked it up to my laptop and tried that. Still no small packets. I tried a different AR7 ADSL router. I downgraded to a 2.6.16.x kernel (which is what my parents are on). All gave the same results; anything over 70 bytes would get through fine, anything under wouldn't.

So I took my router to my parents'. I unplugged their kit and plugged the router in, with only my laptop attached. I left it configured with my username/password. And it worked. Small packets came though fine. To make absolutely certain I tried the same thing again at home. And it didn't work.

Now. Exactly the same kit at my end in both instances. Exactly the same ISP at the other end (who confirm all their end points are configured identically and even if they're not I'd have expected to get a duff one at my parent's once or twice and a working one at my end given the number of reconnections I've made over the period of trying this all out). That leaves BT as the variable (we're about 100 miles apart, so very different exchanges).

My questions to you, the reader:

  • Does this line of logic seem reasonable? If not, what have I missed?
  • Have you ever heard of anything similar? I know BT used to have an issue with IPv6 and PPPoE and corruption of the packet length field, but I'm using PPPoA (I've tried PPPoE as well and it wasn't any better).
  • Is there an ATM packet sniffer for Linux, along the lines of Wireshark? If I could hook up the Speedtouch to my laptop and try a connection while sniffing the ATM packets I could see if there was any corruption or oddities happening at that level, which might provide a clue.

Update: will-h has pointed out it's 70 bytes excluding the PPP header, not including it.

It's a bit cold

(Not a great picture as it's taken with my phone, but I think you'll get the rough gist.)

subscribe via RSS