Will a 200 Watt Supply do this rig?
My machine died the other night, reasonably gracefully, and having decided it must be the PSU I went and bought the only matx one locally in stock. Its 300 Watt, which is what the old one was, and it works but is unbearably noisy. So I am thinking of replacing with a 200 Watt Xilence, which is reviewed in some german mag as being exceptionally quiet. Question: will 200W be enough? Its an i3, one hard drive, no optical, no graphics card and a gigabyte main board in a mini-itx case. My intuition is that it will be just fine because this is such a minimalist setup, but I know nothing about power or how to measure what the draw is. The other choices seem to be silverstone, but they only make them 400W +, and that is certainly over the top. There do not seem to be any fanless ones in this form factor. Al
On Sat, Dec 15, 2012 at 12:27:31PM +0000, Peter Alcibiades wrote:
Its 300 Watt, which is what the old one was, and it works but is unbearably noisy. So I am thinking of replacing with a 200 Watt Xilence, which is reviewed in some german mag as being exceptionally quiet.
Question: will 200W be enough? Its an i3, one hard drive, no optical, no graphics card and a gigabyte main board in a mini-itx case. My intuition is that it will be just fine because this is such a minimalist setup, but I know nothing about power or how to measure what the draw is.
I'd say yes. My I3 with three hard drives in a full sized case uses 44 watts. I did choose the motherboard specifically for low power consumption though. However *none* of my systems consumes much over 100 watts, I think the worst is around 110 watts. -- Chris Green
On 15/12/12 12:27, Peter Alcibiades wrote:
My machine died the other night, reasonably gracefully, and having decided it must be the PSU I went and bought the only matx one locally in stock.
Its 300 Watt, which is what the old one was, and it works but is unbearably noisy. So I am thinking of replacing with a 200 Watt Xilence, which is reviewed in some german mag as being exceptionally quiet.
Question: will 200W be enough? Its an i3, one hard drive, no optical, no graphics card and a gigabyte main board in a mini-itx case. My intuition is that it will be just fine because this is such a minimalist setup, but I know nothing about power or how to measure what the draw is.
The other choices seem to be silverstone, but they only make them 400W +, and that is certainly over the top. There do not seem to be any fanless ones in this form factor.
Is this a standard size PSU or a custom size? I've got a standard sized Xilence 480W which is quiet and works well. I got it from QuietPC.com - I've brought several things from them (quietpc) and they do some good quiet stuff though I expect from what you said that even their minimum output PSU is way over capacity for what you need. Also, all their cheap PSUs seem to be out of stock until the end of the month. HTH Steve
On 15/12/12 12:27, Peter Alcibiades wrote:
My machine died the other night, reasonably gracefully, and having decided it must be the PSU I went and bought the only matx one locally in stock.
Its 300 Watt, which is what the old one was, and it works but is unbearably noisy. So I am thinking of replacing with a 200 Watt Xilence, which is reviewed in some german mag as being exceptionally quiet.
Question: will 200W be enough? Its an i3, one hard drive, no optical, no graphics card and a gigabyte main board in a mini-itx case. My intuition is that it will be just fine because this is such a minimalist setup, but I know nothing about power or how to measure what the draw is.
The other choices seem to be silverstone, but they only make them 400W +, and that is certainly over the top. There do not seem to be any fanless ones in this form factor.
It's not really all about the overall wattage, mostly you need to look at the current capacity of the +12V rails and compare to what one of the online PSU calculators say for your hardware. Modern supplies will be more generous as to what portion of the 200W is available on the 12v rails as modern hardware hits this rail harder in proportion to the others. In the old days the CPU supplies were derived directly from the lower voltage rails.
participants (4)
-
Chris Green -
Peter Alcibiades -
steve-ALUG＠hst.me.uk -
Wayne Stallwood